Perry’s Saturday Night Massacre Continues

by publius Orwell once wrote, "[He] who controls the past, controls the future."  Texas Governor Rick Perry has apparently taken the lesson to heart.  He's now removed a fourth member of the Texas commission responsible for investigating whether Texas (and Perry) executed an innocent man.  It's whitewashing at its worst. By now, you're probably familiar … Read more

Comment Policy, Etc.

by publius Several valued commenters have expressed concern lately that the comments are becoming increasingly hostile, etc.  One aspect of ObWi that I really value is that it's a community for many of the people who visit here frequently and share comments.  For that reason, we try (often unsuccessfully) to maintain basic levels of civility … Read more

The Public Option Dialectic

by publius I'm not sure what the public option's current odds are.  But regardless of the final result, the public option debate itself has been a beneficial and clarifying one for progressives. Generally speaking, political and intellectual coalitions often benefit from schisms that clarify and strengthen the coalition's ultimate positions.  Sometimes, of course, these divisions … Read more

It’s not easy not being Bush

By Lindsay Beyerstein

Not bush nobel cat

It's already a truism that Barack Obama won the Nobel Peace Prize for being not-George W. Bush. This talking point gets repeated as if it's a witty put down. It's supposed to trivialize the win. The implication is that Obama won just for showing up. On closer examination, winning for not being Bush is a pretty substantial distinction in its own right.

Most commentators implicitly assume Obama won just for what he's done as president or what he promises to do in office. In fact, Obama earned the prize for waging a successful campaign to unseat a ruling party that rejected the rule of law at home and abroad. Remember how hard that was?

Much has been made of the fact that nominations for the prize closed in February, just after Obama was sworn in. Obama did take some of his boldest steps towards peace to date during his earliest days in office. One of his first acts was to order the closure of prison at Guantanamo Bay. That was an courageous act of profound national and international significance. He also quickly repudiated the Bush administration's torture policies and shut down its secret prisons.

If the 2008 election happened in Africa or the Middle East it would seem obvious that an opposition leader who restored the rule of law and set about reintegrating his country into the family of nations would be racking up points towards a Nobel Peace Prize before he even took the oath of office.

Read more

Libertarians and Open Networks

by publius Mark Thompson had a thoughtful response to my longer post on the Comcast case and the brief.  It's worth reading the whole thing, but I had a few thoughts and comments. First, I think libertarians like Mark should be siding with the FCC—in this case, siding with the government agency best maximizes liberty. … Read more

Does Chris Christie look fat in this?

By Lindsay Beyerstein NJ governor Jon Corzine's new ad insinuates that his Republican opponent Chris Christie abused his status as a US Attorney to get lenient treatment for two serious traffic infractions. The ad sticks close to the facts: In 2005, Christie was pulled over for going 58 in a 40 zone. It turned out … Read more

A Non-Virtuous Cycle

by publius Previously obscure GA Representative Paul Broun thinks Pelosi is a "domestic enemy of the Constitution."  As a result, he's now getting a bunch of attention.  And while it's an obviously disturbing statement, my fear is that publicizing it only creates incentives for even more extreme statements. More broadly, the rising level of extreme … Read more

A Unified Theory of McCain

by publius Introducing a longer print article, Jay Newton-Small writes: John McCain returned to the Senate in 2000 a virtual liberal: throwing bombs at his Republican leaders (and especially George W. Bush). John McCain returned to the Senate in 2009 a virtual conservative[.] There's a pretty simple explanation for McCain's behavior over the past decade.  … Read more

Stopping the Herd on Coverage Reform

by publius Brendan Nyhan argues that Obama's health care speech didn't have much effect on public opinion.  He notes that disapproval has now returned to previous levels after a brief bump.  Numbers-wise, he's correct.  But I think focusing on the numbers alone misses something very important about the speech — namely, it helped stop the … Read more

We only play the hits

by von I agree with Publius: Pitchfork, after blowing past "trying to hard" and "embarrassing", has finally reached "useless." This has been a long time coming. In 2000, Pitchfork gave Pink Floyd's "Animals" a 10 out of 10. Make no mistake, Animals is a good album. Maybe even a classic. But among the best albums … Read more

Wanna Grow Up to be a Debaser

by Eric Martin

Given the ongoing debate about US policy in Afghanistan, and the interplay of al-Qaeda in that decision making process, some background on al-Qaeda's origins and goals would be worthwhile to examine.

al-Qaeda's ideology and outlook are rooted in an Egyptian, not Saudi or Afghan, tradition (drawing heavily on Qutbism and similar doctrine).  Many of al-Qaeda's founding members are veterans of the struggle between groups of militant Salafists and the secular regimes of Nasser, Sadat and Mubarak.  One of al-Qaeda's central figures, Ayman al-Zawahiri, was a member of a group (Egyptian Islamic Jihad) that was implicated in, amongst other activitites, assassination attempts on Sadat. 

After being imprisoned and tortured for one such assassination plot, an even more radicalized Zawahiri left Egypt for Saudi Arabia and then Pakistan – where he lead a splinter group of Egyptian Islamic Jihad members who were disillusioned with the organization's unwillingness to embrace the takfirist doctrine (or the practice of declaring other Muslims apostates, thus circumventing Koranic prohibitions on the killing of Muslims).

Osama bin Laden, for his part, was one of the 54 children of Muhammed bin Laden - a self made construction mogul of Yemeni nationality (though he relocated to Saudi Arabia at a young age).  His mother was a relatively poor Syrian villager, who was married off to the elder bin Laden at young age, giving birth to Osama at the age of 15.  Ironically, one of the world's most recognizable Saudis is the son of a Yemeni and Syrian.

His path to radicalization began with the tutelage of members of the Muslim Brotherhood (an organization of Egyptian origins) in Saudi Arabia, which teachings were later augmented by al-Zawahiri while both were in Pakistan during the conflict in Afghanistan.  As bin Laden and Zawihiri became close, a nascent, though still formless, precursor to al-Qaeda began to coalesce around a worldview rooted in expansive Salafist/Qutbist thought.  

Soon thereafter, the formerly unwieldy mass of likeminded radicals was whittled down to "the base" or "al-Qaeda."  Two events led to the self selection of al-Qaeda within this context. Initially, when the Afghan campaign ended, many jihadists went back to their nations of origin leaving behind only the most die-hard and those incapable of returning home (often one and the same). Then, this core group (headed by bin Laden himself) migrated to Sudan. bin Laden's group was expelled from that safe-haven in the mid-1990s, and, while some members scattered, bin Laden and his core opted to return to Afghanistan, which again caused a winnowing of the ranks until only the most committed and, increasingly, the most anti-American were left behind to form the vanguard of the Salafist jihadist movement.

The primary raison d'etre of this group, animated by the belief that secular regimes in the Muslim world are quislings of the United States, apostate in character and "against Islam," became to overthrow the corrupt leaders and replace them with proper Islamic rulers and Sharia law (such process to be replicated across the region until there is the contiguous, quasi-mythical, caliphate). By restoring this form of pure Islam, it is believed, the Muslim world will be rewarded by Allah and returned to glory.

Initial attempts to spark revolutions and usher in pure Islamic rule in places like Sudan, Chechnya and the Balkans were unsuccessful, and attacks in places like Egypt were not well received by the locals.  At this point, there was a shift in strategy for the demoralized group. Zawahiri counseled in favor of targeting the "far enemy" (read: the United States) as a means of expediting the toppling of local leaders (the "near enemy").  According to Zawahiri, al-Qaeda could not unseat the target regimes because they were being propped up by the U.S.  If al-Qaeda could cause the US to withdraw its support, however, the regimes would then be vulnerable to usurpation. 

In addition, while targeting fellow Muslims (the representatives of the governments being attacked) was alienating potential recruits, striking the US would galvanize support and create a mass movement that would be primed to topple the regimes once the US was chased from the region. Osama bought into this shift in focus, and began issuing calls for action against the U.S. interests everywhere.

The linchpin to this strategy was to provoke the US into invading a Muslim country (Afghanistan) and thus tie it down for several years of futile - and excessively costly - warfare, while Muslims from throughout the world poured in to join the cause. Then, with the US weakened, bankrupt, fatigued and unable/unwilling to project power and provide resources to its Middle Eastern allies, a reinvigorated al-Qaeda would launch its "near" campaign anew, with its army of new recruits already mobilized.

Read more

Comcast v. FCC: A Brief Overview, and Why You Should Care

by John Blevins and Marvin Ammori (I'm using my real name because this piece is both co-authored and will be x-posted at Balkinization.  I'll update with link when it gets posted.  publius). Yesterday, a group of law professors and public interest organizations (listed below) filed briefs in Comcast v. FCC in the DC Circuit court—a … Read more

Round Two

(Also known as: A Stimulus for Tomorrow, Part 10) by von Everyone should have seen this coming …. well, everyone who reads these here Wings of Obsidian.  From Salon (citing Bloomberg and The New York Times): Call it the the stimulus that dare not be named. Bloomberg reports that the Obama administration is considering "a mix of spending … Read more

Where I’ve Been

by publius Sorry for the non-posting of late, but I can explain.  I helped file an amicus brief today in the Comcast litigation in the DC Circuit.  I promise I'll explain it all in more detail later (and provide links to the brief for those interested).  But now, must rest.

Why I Don’t Read Pitchfork

by publius I suppose it's funny if they're doing it ironically.  If not, then not so much.  Here's the review of Air's new one, if you can bear it: A half-decade of Balearic/glo-fi/'lude-house has since refined that mellow aesthetic to the point where taste-conscious end-runs around potential irony have become increasingly unnecessary. But while that … Read more

[Podcast] Journo: I love my “socialist” kidney

Most people think of single payer health care in America as something akin to science fiction–a bold idea that might be possible someday, but certainly not an option in the here and now. Journalist Jennifer Nix points out that the U.S. already has single payer care, not only for the aged (Medicare) and the poor … Read more

For the Good of the People

by Eric Martin In the debate over the future of US policy in Afghanistan, it is taken as a given by most proponents of prolonging the occupation that our presence is benefiting the Afghan people.  According to this view, we are a bulwark against Taliban aggression – a prophylactic for a liberal-minded, yet vulnerable, contingent of Afghan … Read more