by hilzoy
After posting yesterday’s poem, I realized to my shame and horror that I had been indulging a bias in favor of good poetry. I was mortified: how, after all, can one justify privileging quality? Doesn’t justice require a special effort to overcome the natural yet indefensible tendency to discriminate in favor of excellence? Shouldn’t we strive to be inclusive, giving everyone a voice, regardless of whether they conform to our narrow, historically situated notions of “talent”? Isn’t the very idea of “good” poetry just a reification of our contemporary biases constructed by narrow-minded academics to protect their arbitrary disciplinary fiefdoms? With such thoughts in mind, I have decided to rectify my previous errors by posting works by James McIntyre (1827-1906), the Ontario Cheese Poet. (He was not trying to be funny when he wrote and published these works, as far as I know.) I have put one above the fold and a few more below, because after all, is it really possible to have too much of a bad thing? (Don’t answer that.) (But do read at least the first below the fold, ‘Ode on the Mammoth Cheese’. It’s amazing.)
Prophecy of a Ten Ton Cheese
Who hath prophetic vision sees
In future times a ten ton cheese,
Several companies could join
To furnish curd for great combine
More honor far than making gun
Of mighty size and many a ton.
Machine it could be made with ease
That could turn this monster cheese,
The greatest honour to our land
Would be this orb of finest brand,
Three hundred curd they would need squeeze
For to make this mammoth cheese.
So British lands could confederate
Three hundred provinces in one state,
When all in harmony agrees
To be pressed in one like this cheese,
Then one skillful hand could acquire
Power to move British empire.
But various curds must be combined
And each factory their curd must grind,
To blend harmonious in one
This great cheese of mighty span,
And uniform in quality
A glorious reality.
But it will need a powerful press
This cheese queen to caress,
And a large extent of charms
Hoop will encircle in its arms,
And we do not now despair,
But we shall see it at world’s fair.
And view the people all agog, so
Excited o’er it in Chicago,
To seek fresh conquests queen of cheese
She may sail across the seas,
Where she would meet reception grand
From the warm hearts in old England.
– James McIntyre
Ode on the Mammoth Cheese
We have seen the Queen of cheese,
Laying quietly at your ease,
Gently fanned by evening breeze —
Thy fair form no flies dare seize.
All gaily dressed soon you’ll go
To the great Provincial Show,
To be admired by many a beau
In the city of Toronto.
Cows numerous as a swarm of bees —
Or as the leaves upon the trees —
It did require to make thee please,
And stand unrivalled Queen of Cheese.
May you not receive a scar as
We have heard that Mr. Harris
Intends to send you off as far as
The great World’s show at Paris.
Of the youth — beware of these —
For some of them might rudely squeeze
And bite your cheek; then songs or glees
We could not sing o’ Queen of Cheese.
We’rt thou suspended from baloon,
You’d cast a shade, even at noon;
Folks would think it was the moon
About to fall and crush them soon.
Nova Scotia
If you are sulky, Nova Scotia,
We’ll gladly let you float away
From out our Confederation;
You sicken us with sily agitation.
If any more our patience you do tax
We’ll let you go to Halifax.
Dairy Ode
Our muse it doth refuse to sing
Of cheese made early in the spring,
When cows give milk from spring fodder
You cannot make a good cheddar.
The quality is often vile
Of cheese that is made in April,
Therefore we think for that reason
You should make later in the season.
Cheese making you should delay
Until about the first of May.
Then cows do feed on grassy field
And rich milk they abundant yield.
Ontario cannot compete
With the Northwest in raising wheat,
For cheaper there they it can grow
So price in future may be low.
Though this a hardship it may seem,
Rejoice that you have got the cream,
In this land of milk and honey,
Where dairy farmers do make money.
Utensils must be clean and sweet,
So cheese with first class can compete,
And daily polish up milk pans,
Take pains with vats and with milk cans.
And it is important matter
To allow no stagnant water,
But water from pure well or stream
The cow must drink to give pure cream.
Canadian breeds ’tis best to pair
With breeds from the shire of Ayr,
They thrive on our Canadian feed
And are for milking splendid breed.
Though ‘gainst spring cheese some do mutter,
Yet spring milk also makes bad butter,
Then there doth arise the query
How to utilize it in the dairy.
The milk it floats in great spring flood
Though it is not so rich and good,
Let us be thankful for this stream
Of milk and also curds and cream.
All dairymen their highest aims
Should be to make the vale of Thames,
Where milk doth so abundant flow,
Dairyland of Ontario.
— James McIntyre (more of his poems can be found here.)
When the going gets tough
And the stomach acids flow
The cold wind of conformity
Is nipping at your nose
When some trendy new atrocity
Has brought you to your knees
Come with us we’ll sail the
Seas of Cheese
from Primus’s “Sailing the Seas of Cheese”
In Praise of Elitists
I come not to bury the elite, but to praise them. No, not the “elite” who are anything but, over-promoted scions of wealthy families dull of wit and duller of mind, there by grace of Poppy be. No, I come to praise the true elite, the thinkers, the doers, the creators of science and writers of texts, those who spent years or decades studying their field and years more working in it, those of sharp wit and clear minds. For who should we wish this nation to be led by — a true elite of the best and the brightest, or by dullards and know-nothings, prayersome scions of ignorance and hate? And who, amongst us, would do the better job — the true elite, or the dullards and bubbas who worship upon the altar of their Lord and Savior, George W. Bush, and His holy appointed administration of fellow dullards?
I come today not to bury elitism, but to praise it. For it has become clear that government of the ignorant, by the ignorant, for the benefit of a few dullards who have a talent for criminal graft and the accumulation of silly baubles, is hardly conducive to health, prosperity, or the general welfare. Elitism: It’s not only not a dirty word, but may be a good idea.
– Badtux the Elitist Penguin
Daddy do it, oh, just do it
Daddy do it, please let me see
Daddy do it, please just do it daddy
Do it, do it, do it, drivin' me crazy
– Steven Tyler “Cheesecake”
No collection of bad poetry is complete without at least one poem by the world’s official Worst Poet, William Topaz McGonagall. (If you doubt his status, google on “worst poet”.)
I was unsure which gems of his work to share with you, but finally decided that a poem with an American theme was most appropriate:
Jottings of New York, by William McGonagall
OH mighty City of New York! you are wonderful to behold,
Your buildings are magnificent, the truth be it told,
They were the only things that seemed to arrest my eye,
Because many of them are thirteen storeys high.
And as for Central Park, it is lovely to be seen
Especially in the summer season when its shrubberies and trees are green;
And the Burns’ statue is there to be seen,
Surrounded by trees, on the beautiful sward so green;
Also, Shakespeare and Sir Walter Scott,
Which by Englishmen and Scotsmen will ne’er be forgot.
There the people on the Sabbath-day in thousands resort,
All loud in conversation and searching for sport,
Some of them viewing the menagerie of wild beasts there,
And also beautiful black swans, I do declare.
And there’s beautiful boats to be seen there,
And the joyous shouts of the children do rend the air,
While the boats sail along with them o’er Lohengrin Lake,
And the fare is five cents for children and adults ten is all they take.
And there’s also summer-house shades and merry-go-rounds,
And with the merry laughter of the children the Park resounds
During the livelong Sabbath-day,
Enjoying the merry-go-round play.
Then there’s the elevated railroads, about five storeys high,
Which the inhabitants can see and hear night and day passing by,
Oh! such a mass of people daily do throng,
No less than five hundred thousand daily pass along,
And all along the City you can get for five cents,
And, believe me, among the passengers there are few discontent.
And the top of the houses are all flat,
And in the warm weather the people gather to chat,
Besides on the house tops they dry their clothes,
And also many people all night on the house-tops repose.
And numerous ships and steamboats are there to be seen,
Sailing along the East River Water so green;
‘Tis certainly a most beautiful sight
To see them sailing o’er the smooth water day and night.
And Brooklyn Bridge is a very great height,
And fills the stranger’s heart with wonder at first sight,
But with all its loftiness, I venture to say,
For beauty it cannot surpass the new Railway Bridge of the Silvery Tay.
And there’s also ten thousand rumsellers there,
Oh! wonderful to think, I do declare
To accomodate the people of that city therein,
And to encourage them to commit all sorts of sin.
And on the Sabbath-day, ye will see many a man
Going for beer with a tin can,
And seems proud to be seen carrying home the beer
To treat his neighbours and family dear.
Then at night numbers of the people dance and sing,
Making the walls of their houses to ring
With their songs and dancing on Sabbath night,
Which I witnessed with disgust, and fled from the sight.
And with regard to New York and the sights I did see,
One street in Dundee is worth more to me,
And, believe me, the morning I sailed from New York
For Bonnie Dundee, my heart it felt as light as a cork.
fail, prithee, dominatrix rex
to walk upright, gaberdeen slacks
knees worn dirty, besmirched. wrecked
lipstick intruder welcome. regress.
want some really bad poetry?
check this out, lol
Hey the bawds among you may want to go take a look at Immortalia: An Anthology of American Ballads, Sailors’ Songs, Cowboy Songs, College Songs, Parodies, Limericks, and other humorous verses and doggerel — it is online at http://www.immortalia.com/html/books-OCRed/1927-immortalia/ — I particularly like the take on Poe’s “The Raven” which is on page 146.
I don’t know.
I keep thinking that these McIntyre verses are really subtly ironic comments on the monarchy.
For instance,
“Three hundred curd they would need squeeze
For to make this mammoth cheese.
So British lands could confederate
Three hundred provinces in one state,
When all in harmony agrees
To be pressed in one like this cheese,
Then one skillful hand could acquire
Power to move British empire”
seems to be an argument against at-large elections under the British Parliamentary system (favoring regional “in-riding” elections as is now the case). Viewed in this light, such following verses as
“But various curds must be combined
And each factory their curd must grind”
“But it will need a powerful press
This cheese queen to caress,
And a large extent of charms
Hoop will encircle in its arms”
“To seek fresh conquests queen of cheese
She may sail across the seas,
Where she would meet reception grand
From the warm hearts in old England”
seem to be sly – and not entirely unapproving – comments on labor unionism, the military strength of the United Kingdom, and empirialism, respectively.
Allow me to say also, in passing, that
“view the people all agog, so
Excited o’er it in Chicago”
is perhaps the finest single rhyming couplet ever penned.
At any rate, once having adopted the “political” view of McIntyre’s deathless prose, similar readings of his other works suggest themselves with an almost irresistible immediacy. Consider, for instance . . .
“We have seen the Queen of cheese,
Laying quietly at your ease,
Gently fanned by evening breeze —
Thy fair form no flies dare seize.”
If you merely remove the words “of cheese” from the above stanza, it reveals itself as an almost treasonously sarcastic remark upon the “parasitic monarchy” (one presumes McIntyre’s politics changed radically between “Prophecy on a Ten Ton Cheese” and “Ode on the Mammoth Cheese”).
“All gaily dressed soon you’ll go
To the great Provincial Show,
To be admired by many a beau
In the city of Toronto.”
and
“May you not receive a scar as
We have heard that Mr. Harris
Intends to send you off as far as
The great World’s show at Paris.”
grant similar readings, in this case remarking upon the monarch’s penchant for swanning around the capitals of Europe and the Empire, while
“Of the youth — beware of these —
For some of them might rudely squeeze
And bite your cheek; then songs or glees
We could not sing o’ Queen of Cheese”
is a quite daringly ribald jest at old Queen Victoria – known not to be averse to having her cheeks squeezed or (possibly) bitten. (One remembers, here, to elide the words “of Cheese” in interpreting this verse, naturally.)
And, of course, the meaning of McIntyre’s “Nova Scotia” cannot be clearer:
“If you are sulky, Nova Scotia,
We’ll gladly let you float away
From out our Confederation;
You sicken us with sily agitation.”
The “Dairy Ode”, I admit, is not so revealing of hidden political meanings, but I prefer to regard it as a patriotic pastoral extolling the virtues of the various Canadian provinces (and thereby foretelling, in its way, the similar sentiments of the Beach Boys’ vernal ode, “California Girls”).
Truly, this was a master of the subdued glance and the poignard wit. An overlooked genius of the cud and the curd.
It’s easy to grin,
when your ship comes in,
and you’ve got the stock market beat.
But the man that’s worthwile,
is the man that can smile,
when his pants are too tight in the seat.
Naeional Poetry Month?
When nature’s callin’,
don’t be stallin’,
use your common sense!
Before you let it flow,
find a place to go,
just don’t whiz on the electric fence!
Jim Rome’s haiku ode to Rae Carruth:
I shot my wife dead.
Didn’t want to be a dad.
I live in a cage.
A Jim Rome name-check on Obsidian Wings? Rack him!
I especially liked the way that he makes us pronounce “Scotia” as “Skoat-ee-ay”, in order to rhyme with “float away”.
Real quality will always reveal itself in points like this.
Naeional Poetry Month?
Elitist!
So did you misspell national to make the anti-elitists feel more comfortable?
Nope; a pure mistake.Tried to correct it; Typepad was uncooperative; then I decided that a spelling mistake in this particular title had something to be said for it, so I left it alone.
Per W. Zaranka, in The Brand-X Anthology of Poetry:
Does Modernist Poetry lack the milk of humankindness? Is art Modern insofar as it does not resemble the human, as Ortega y Gasket suggests? Perhaps Donald Davies Daiches is right when he criticizes Eliot’s poetry for lacking “scope and [human] sympathy.” On the other hand, the work of William Bluster Yeast seems overflowing with milk. In such poems as “The Man Who Dreamed of Dairyland” and “The Second Camembert,” Yeast writes: “Churning and churning in the widening Gruyere,/Surely the Second Camembert is at hand.” Here Yeast is echoing the sentiment expressed by Hardy’s Tess in “Neuter Tones,” where occurs the famous smellie: “And the sun was white as though cheddar of God.” Both poets, of course, owe a debt to the Milton of Samsoe Agonistes, and to Wordsworth, whose “The Ruined Cottage Cheese,” like much of the poetry of Frost, takes place in the luggage really used by men. Milton and Wordsworth set the standards for gerontions of Cheese (and later, Snack) Poets, including John Hausman, author of “Loveliest of Cheese, the Cheshire Now” and “With Rue My Heart is Leyden,” Wallace Stevens, author of “Anecdote of the Jarlsberg” and “The Emperor of Cream Cheese,” and Robert Graves, author of “The White Gouda” (cf. Robinson’s “Minerva Cheesy”) and “Muriel Rukase.” But it is to the mature Yeast, whose career spans the end of one fin de siecle, the nineteenth, and the beginning of another, the twentieth, we must go for the greatest Cheese poems in the English language (the Greek poet Constantine Havarti is recognized as the world’s most important). Most of these poems were composed during the Boston Celtic Twilight which Yeast, indisputably the greatest English poet in Ireland, immobilized forever. The most frequently anthologozied of these, and therefore the best, is the poem Yeast dedicated to the aging naturalist Maud Gorgonnezola, with whom he was in love most of his life. It is, of course, “Liederkranz and the Swan” composed under Ben Bulben, “where are the Lieders start,/In the foul wine-and-cheese shop of the heart.” Surely, here is poetry possessed of all the milk of humankindness a reader could wish.