The Coming Trump-Cruz GOP Ticket – Open Thread

by Ugh It seems Scott Walker is an incredibly bad candidate and all foam/no beer to boot.  We have Trump running circles around him and the rest of the, uh, distinguished gentlemen (and Ms. Fiorina) with nothing more than his hair and "BLARGH! I STRONG!" as a campaign.  Jeebus. So, despite my earlier thought that … Read more

Gene Engineering Open Thread

by wj OK, we need a new open thread. I get that. So here ya go. Once upon a time, I read a science fiction story which featured a group called “Control Normals”. (No, I don’t recall who the author was or what the title was. Perhaps one of the SF fans here will remember.) … Read more

Why Do Bad Things Happen? — Open Thread

by wj Last night we had the traditional annual family gathering to celebrate the birthdays of all of us born in late July and early August. (Which amounts to nearly half of us.) As always, the conversation ranged far and wide. But at one point, someone mentioned a colleague who is a conspiracy theory enthusiast. … Read more

Kurdistan and Somaliland

by wj What do these two “countries” have in common? Officially, they don’t exist. In reality, of course, both control substantial swaths of territory (which used to be part of another country, which is collapsed or collapsing), are relatively well governed democracies, and have economies in far better shape than that of the country that … Read more

how’s this gonna turn out…?

by russell saw this on NPR initially, now it's at Field and Stream of all places. I'm actually really curious to see how this shakes out, legally. For the record, I don't really have a problem with people blasting camera-bearing drones out of the sky if they are hovering over their property.  A 2nd Amendment solution to … Read more

GOP Debate: Dumpster fire or Performance Art? Open Thread

by Ugh And so it begins.  Predictions?  Thoughts?  Winners/losers?  Will Donald's hairpiece walk off the stage?  Who will make the most outrageous statement?  Who helped most/least? My prediction:  Mr. Trump "wins" hands down.  Jeb Bush's popularity goes down.  Scott Walker will say the most insane thing and his popularity will soar because of it. Anyway, … Read more

But we couldn’t possibly prosecute anyone

by Ugh Because, gosh, there just isn't any evidence.  We're looking forward, not back.   Ex-CIA boss admits to BBC Panorama that it tortured The CIA tortured terror suspects in its programme of "enhanced interrogation", the agency's former executive director, Buzzy Krongard, has admitted to the BBC's Panorama programme. … I asked Buzzy Krongard, the … Read more

Breaking Bad and Smallville: Tragedy as a TV genre

by Doctor Science

I never saw Breaking Bad — it’s really not my kind of thing, too morally dark and too realistic (no dragons, no spaceships) — but I could hardly avoid being aware of it. This was especially the case as it built to the finale in September 2013.

The reaction to the “Breaking Bad” finale on my social media sites (Tumblr, Livejournal/Dreamwidth, Facebook), both while it was airing and immediately afterward, was: “I’m weeping for the characters. What a great, satisfying ending.” As I saw viewers’ reactions, it was clear to me: “Breaking Bad” is tragedy in the classical sense. It depicts a person of noble character (in Walter White’s case, a man of intelligence and talent) overthrown by fate and their own flaws, evoking emotions of pity and terror, and leading the audience to a feeling of catharsis.

No wonder “Breaking Bad” is held in such high critical esteem: tragedy is still the most prestigious of genres, in Western drama, and the tragic sequence of emotions is still our standard for Most Important Art.

Mrs_Siddons_by_Joshua_Reynolds

Mrs Siddons as the Tragic Muse, with Pity (holding a cup) and Terror (holding a knife) to either side. Image from Wikipedia.

Read more